Thinking Negation in Early Hinduism & Classical Indian Philosophy
- 5 Downloads
A number of different kinds of negation and negation of negation are developed in Indian thought, from ancient religious texts to classical philosophy. The chapter explores the Mīmāṃsā, Nyāya, Jaina and Buddhist theorizing on the various forms and permutations of negation, denial, nullity, nothing and nothingness, or emptiness. The main thesis argued for is that in the broad Indic tradition, negation cannot be viewed as a mere classical operator turning the true into the false (and conversely), nor reduced to the mainstream Boolean dichotomy: 1 vs 0. Special attention is given to how contradiction is handled in Jaina and Buddhist logic.
KeywordsNegation Mīmāṃsa Nyāya Buddhist logic Jaina anekāntavāda Priestian dialetheism
Mathematics Subject ClassificationPrimary 03A05 Secondary 03-03 · 01-02.
I wish to express gratitude for the immense guidance I received from Jayshankar Lal Shaw and Anand Vaidya toward revising the chapter. I also thank (the late) Frits Staal, (the late) Bimal K. Matilal, Stephen Phillips, my students in Berkeley. The editors of this volume and an anonymous referee have also provided invaluable feedback from the time of the conference to this point in the process.
- Bhargava, Dayananda. 1973. The Jaina Tarka Bhasha of Acharya Yashovijaya. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass Publishers.Google Scholar
- Bilimoria, P. 2008. Nietzsche as ‘Europe’s Buddha’ and Asia’s Superman. Sophia (Guest Issue on Continental Philosophy of Religion) 47(3); 359-376.Google Scholar
- Bilimoria, P., A. Vaidya, and J.L. Shaw. 2016. Absence – An Indo analytic study. Sophia (Special Issue on 25th Anniversary of the Demise of Professor Bimal K Matilal) 55 (4): 491–513.Google Scholar
- Inada, K.K. 1993. Nāgārjuna: A translation of his Mūlamadhyamakakārikā with an introductory essay. Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications.Google Scholar
- ———. 1981. Central philosophy of Jainism: Anekāntavāda. L D Institute of Indology, AhmedabadGoogle Scholar
- ———. 1991. Anekānta: Both yes and no. Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research 8: 1–12.Google Scholar
- Pacitti, Domenico. 1991. Negation in Sanskrit: Rig Veda X,129. The nature of the negative, edited by Pacitti, D, Pisa: Giardini. http://www.pacitti.org/books_00199102.htm (accessed 25/02/2015)
- Sebastian, C.D. 2016. The cloud of nothingness: The negative way in Nāgārjuna and John of the cross. In Sophia studies in cross-cultural philosophy of traditions and cultures. New Delhi/Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
- ———. 1981. Negation: some Indian theories. In Studies in Indian philosophy, ed. D. Malvania and N.J. Shah, 57–78. Ahmedabad: L D Institute of Indology.Google Scholar
- ———. 2016a. Austin on falsity and negation. In The collected writings of Jaysankar Lal Shaw: Indian analytic and Anglophone philosophy, 197–200. London: Bloomsbury Academic.Google Scholar
- ———. 2016b. Descriptions: Contemporary philosophy and the Nyaya. In The collected writings of Jaysankar Lal Shaw: Indian analytic and Anglophone philosophy, 328–361. London: Bloomsbury Academic.Google Scholar
- ———. 2016c. The Nyāya on double negation. In The collected writings of Jaysankar Lal Shaw: Indian analytic and anglophone philosophy, 224–237. London: Bloomsbury Academic.Google Scholar
- Staal, Frits J.(1962) 1988. Negation and the law of contradiction in Indian thought: A comparative study. Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, 52-71. Reprinted, in Staal, F. J. Universal Studies in Indian logic and linguistics. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 112–113Google Scholar
- Williams, P., ed. 2005. Buddhism critical concepts in religious studies. Vol. Vol. IV. London: Abhidharma and Madhyamaka. Routledge.Google Scholar